Join our
LinkedIn Group

Supplier Spotlight

Latest Videos

A message for Virgin America

LAX Video

Alas Virgin America is soon to vanish, becoming part of Alaska Airlines. Here's Virgin Atlantic's fond farewell from across The Pond

28 March 2017

Low-cost airlines – Doris Day style!

LAX Video

This classic episode of the Doris Day Show sees Doris brave the low-cost airline experience. She can't complain about her seat allocation though: just look at that legroom!

20 March 2017

Acumen on the BBC

LAX Video

Ian Dryburgh, founder of Acumen Design Associates, appeared on the BBC's Inside Track news program to discuss aircraft seating innovation. This was a great chance to introduce a wider audience to the industrial design involved in aircraft cabins, and to offer a little insight into how they work.

14 March 2017

Visit Our YouTube Channel

Read Latest Issue

Industry Opinion

« back to blog listings

Wide of the mark

Daniel Baron of Lift Strategic Design says talk of twin aisles on narrow-body aircraft misses the point

So what’s going to replace the Boeing 737 and Airbus A320? I keep hearing tantalising talk of a twin-aisle solution featuring a 2-2-2 economy cabin. True, 2-2-2 would indeed mean less anxiety prior to the trip. Even if unable to pre-book an aisle or window seat, none of the last-minute options would be as nightmarish as they are now. Stress levels would decrease over a wide spectrum of humanity. Global peace might break out.

But assuming that the economics allowed for a slightly wider cabin, would 2-2-2 actually save the world? Using the standard seat and armrest widths, it would not address a critical issue: nobody actually wants to sit closely to anyone, unless the seatmate in question is a family member, partner or target of a sexual conquest. 2-2-2 with conventional spacing would not reverse the reality that we humans are getting larger (in every direction), and that our elbows often commit involuntary violation of borders during intensive typing and passionate game-playing. Ditto for long legs straying into aisles. Our shapes and behaviours have rendered the current dimensions utterly redundant.

Twin aisles would not be the holy grail of service delivery either. Cabin crew numbers aren’t going up anytime soon, and ruthless seat packing might necessitate long marches back to the galley. Human overflow would mean collisions between passengers and carts in two aisles, not just one.

All carriers have access to sophisticated yield management software. Now what they really need is a super-flexible, convertible, narrow-body cabin that enables them to sell different products depending on market, sector length and/or time of day, with no extra labour for configuration changes. The future narrow-body cabin should therefore give lateral space between passengers precedence over number of aisles. How to achieve this? Simple. A slightly wider fuselage in a 3-3 configuration, with current seatback widths – but with wider centre armrests. The primary benefit: even with a 100% load factor, all customers get more ‘breathing space’ and the middle seat is no longer akin to medieval torture. The extra inches in each triple would mean additional space under and above seats for stowage, slightly deeper closets and lavatories, and a pinch of new vertical space in the galleys.

A wider triple would deliver the quick product change flexibility that airlines need. The aircraft could perform single-class, short-haul sectors during the day and then overnight flights with the spacious triples sold to a single customer at a premium, with sleep pad, comforter and pillow included. No additional dividers or labour time would be necessary. The à la carte enhanced offering would be popular with business travellers forced to fly economy. Many of these road warriors would pay out of their own pocket for the guaranteed ability to get horizontal (conquests aside).

These fabulous additional inches would also create new possibilities for business-class seat designs, and for long-haul niche players who want to offer a high-density, low-fare affair in the back but ‘owner class’ luxury up front.

Conventional categories continue to blur as airlines tweak their models to cut costs and increase revenue. Creative tweaking is the new norm, and product differentiation remains critical for brand loyalty. At the heart of my wild ‘wide 3-3’ concept is a cabin designed for today’s needs, with built-in flexibility for tomorrow.


Daniel Baron is managing director of LIFT Strategic Design, a Tokyo-based brand and design consultancy whose clients include LAN, China Airlines, Philippine Airlines, Oasis Hong Kong Airlines, IMDC and Jamco. He has lived in Asia for 20 years.


24 August 2010


There are currently no comments.

If you would like to post a comment about this blog, please click here.
Read Latest Issue

Read Latest Issue

Web Exclusives

Human-machine interface technology is advancing to be more intuitive and to integrate seamlessly into overall cabin concepts in order to to meet the changing demands of aircraft interior design  
Click here to read more

APEX is embracing the digital content ecosystem as it adopts DECE’s Common Format as ‘the single deliverable format for all IFEC uses’
Click here to read more

United Airlines wanted the seemingly impossible for its new business class: greater sleep comfort and direct aisle access without losing seat density. Aircraft Interiors International attended the preview event of Polaris, one of the biggest business class seating projects ever, to get the full story
Click here to read more

A single inflight wi-fi access point might need to connect to more than 100 client devices, ranging from first-generation smart phones to the latest two stream 802.11ac laptops and tablets. Let's consider the importance of successful and reliable connections, and network security
Click here to read more

Commencing operations is a huge task for an airline, but that didn't deter start-up Indian carrier Vistara from also taking the bold step of becoming the launch customer for an IFE system
Click here to read more

Submit your industry opinion

Industry BlogDo you have an opinion you'd like to share with the aircraft interiors community? Good or bad, we'd like to hear your views and opinions on the leading issues shaping the industry. Share your comments by sending up to 500 words to

Submit Your Recruitment Ad

Recruitment AdTo send us your recruitment advertising or to receive information on placing a banner please email