Latest Videos

The best first class in the world?

Jetwave_video

The face of Emirates has changed from Jennifer Aniston to… Jeremy Clarkson? Join Jeremy as he explains the features of the new Boeing 777 first class suites

16 November, 2017


Fly Transpose

Jetwave_video

You’ve seen the renderings and read our DETAILED FEATURE, and now you can really get a feel for the Transpose modular concept created by Airbus’s A3 division

16 November, 2017


Visit Our YouTube Channel

Read Latest Issue

Three redesigned first class suites are due to be revealed imminently. Which do you think will be the
most impressive?

Supplier Spotlight

Join our
LinkedIn Group


Industry Opinion

« back to blog listings

Uncomfortable reading about aircraft seating

There are many factors that influence how pleasurable a flight might be, including interior design, in-flight entertainment, food quality, luggage storage and service. There is one aspect of the experience, however, which can render the others insignificant if it isn’t good. And that is the seat.

I’ll come back to business class seating later but most of us turn right when we board. And let’s face it, how many times has anyone flown in economy class and complimented the crew on the supremely comfortable seats, which had plenty of legroom and were so easy to adjust into the perfect position?

As I’m sure most people appreciate, economy class seats are built to a price, and therefore we should put up with what we get. What rubbish! Why then, is it so rare to find a comfortable seat? There are many factors which go into this question, not least the fact that we human beings come in all shapes and sizes, so what one person finds comfortable, another may not.

Another problem is that comfort is difficult to measure. In the absence of a ‘comfort-o-meter’, we need to look at a number of factors such as traditional ergonomic posture assessment, pressure mapping and of course, benchmarking. Whilst comfortable economy seats may be rare, they do exist and so measuring the parameters on what are considered ‘good’ seats has to be part of the mix, and should be carried out at the end of a flight with multiple users. A five-minute assessment by a CEO, no matter how well calibrated their backside might be, is not an objective test!

And so to business class. With long haul, almost every major airline offers seats that convert to lie-flat beds as a part of the package. I’m fortunate to have tried a few different airlines’ offers, and I find it hard to differentiate between them. The storage differs, the IFE screen operates in a different way, some face backwards, but when it comes to the acid test – how comfortable they are when both upright and flat – I wouldn’t single out any particular solution.

They’re all pretty good, but my big question is: are they as good as they could be? And I mean that in every aspect, from design, to visual appeal, comfort, manufacturing cost, ease of installation and reliability. As an engineer (not a designer), I doubt it.

So, having decided that this might be an area where NTDC could add some real value to the industry, I attendedAircraft Interiors Expo in Hamburg, back in April. For me, it was an absolute triumph… of hope over expectation. What I saw was a large number of incremental designs, just nudging the standard forward a little at a time; I only saw a couple of examples of what I thought were genuinely innovative solutions, and nothing that I would describe as disruptive.

Before you start reaching for the pen or the keyboard to complain, I know this is a highly regulated sector, and rightly so; but I also believe that there needs to be some ‘out of the box’ thinking if we’re to create step changes and revolutionary design solutions, and I believe that we can do that whilst respecting regulations.

If only there were a National Centre somewhere, set up to engage with the transport design community and users, to push the envelope and research disruptive solutions – all in a modern building with state-of-the-art facilities…

David Wright, Coventry University’s director of strategic initiatives, is responsible for the execution of the National Transport Design Centre (NTDC) project

 

 

17 August 2017

Comments:

While there have been some improvements on business and first class seats, I think the industry focuses on the economics of the economy seats rather than comfort. The seat over time has become smaller, armrests narrower, cushions thinner and of course legroom smaller. All those factors have contributed to lots of incidents and arguments among passengers.

I think it's time to do a full re-evaluation of the comfort aspects of the economy seat.



Bill Najd, chief engineer, Zodiac Aerospace


I agree with these comments. I likewise found it frustrating that, whilst we have seen advancements in passenger comfort levels in first and business class, we have seen little in economy. This was the primary motivation for the introduction of the seat design by Sleepertech, particularly suited for long-haul flights.



Gordon Croudace, Sleepertech


If you would like to post a comment about this blog, please click here.
RECEIVE THE
LATEST NEWS


Your email address:



Read Latest Issue

Read Latest Issue

Web Exclusives

From our 2004 archive, Boeing invites you to step aboard Flight 960 with Jenny, one of a host of fictional characters that Boeing was using to explore tomorrow's travel experience. Jenny was envisioned as a passenger in 2016, so see how today's experience compares…
Click here to read more

Airbus is consolidating cabin design and the passenger experience across its model range with the Airspace brand, which may just gain airlines a few more ‘likes’ on social media
Click here to read more

The Desire Lines concept has been conceived to shape a new future for the aerospace industry – and for Zodiac Aerospace
Click here to read more

The SportJet isn’t just another concept: this airborne sports clinic is part of Sukhoi’s strategy to boost sales of the SuperJet 100 regional aircraft, and it is ready for team orders
Click here to read more

Could a freighter hold the secret to the next-generation passenger experience? A3, an Airbus outpost in California, believes that with its Transpose concept, it does. Let’s give Transpose a closer look – and a reality check
Click here to read more


Supplier Spotlight

Supplier SpotlightClick here for listings and information on leading suppliers covering all aspects of the aircraft interiors industry. Want to see your company included? Contact simon.hughes@ukimediaevents.com for more details.

فروشگاه اینترنتی فروشگاه اینترنتی سیستم همکاری در فروش ماهواره جیبی اندروید کانال تلگرام چت روم ماهواره آنلاین اندروید دانلود فیلم فروشگظ;ه اینترنتی

Submit your industry opinion

Industry BlogDo you have an opinion you'd like to share with the aircraft interiors community? Good or bad, we'd like to hear your views and opinions on the leading issues shaping the industry. Share your comments by sending up to 500 words to adam.gavine@ukimediaevents.com

Submit Your Recruitment Ad

Recruitment AdTo send us your recruitment advertising or to receive information on placing a banner please email simon.hughes@ukimediaevents.com